Friday, May 14, 2004

What have we descended to? The events of the past few weeks are very disturbing. The culmination of a surreal set of events, and one that makes me confident there is no hope for humanity. We are doomed.

If we are to ignore the conspiracy theorists, Saddam was a tyrant who performed atrocities against his people, but does that justify a war? A war where 20,000 civilians die? 20,000. They're just numbers, no? I can't imagine it, 20,000 people with lives, stories, family. 20,000 people with a consciousness much like my own, all dead. 20,000. Wow. And for what?

But of course, sometimes you need war to bring about peace, right? What about Hitler? Was WW2 justified then? Surely the civilian casualties there were overshadowed by the evil that was stopped?

Or do the "you can't place a value on a human life" arguments hold? "Life, woman, is God's most precious gift, and no principle, no matter how glorious, may justify the taking of it". Isn't that just hiding behind pretty prose? An intellectual approach that doesn't hold in the real world? I don't know, probably.

But of course, you have to ask, was war the only way out? Was there not another way? I truly don't know. Perhaps war was the only option if Saddam was to be removed. Perhaps diplomatic channels were all doomed to failure. I don't know.

And if the war was justified, are the US any better than Saddam? But the abuses are not indicative of the whole US army. Yet the growing number of reports suggests a fundamental lack of preparation and comprehension of the seriousness of war (something I don't presume to have). There doesn't seem to be a moral centre anymore, it's a free-for-all. Maybe the war makes you crazy. Kill enough people and you can't tell friend from foe.

"Who cares?", asked a US soldier. Indeed. I wonder.

Does Berg's horrific killing overshadow the abuse? Surely abuse is one thing and murder another. But the abuse held particular shame due to the culture over there. And yet, murder is murder is murder. It is understandable that the abuse would be reacted to unfavourably. But murder is a sickening retaliation. But what if it's the only way they'll learn? But it's murder.

Questions, too many questions, and no answers. Perhaps both sides are right. Or perhaps the truth lies in between. Whatever. To hell with reason and logic, I've had enough.

I want to read the history books of tomorrow.

1 comment:

Jenny said...

there isn't a single person I've ever talked to who isn't heavily influenced by (a) the information they have (perhaps from the media? etc) and (b) the information they don't have. (and I've talked to me multiple times too ^_^)

and there isn't a single person I've met who doesn't act upon what they think they believe and know.. and people die because of this in extreme cases? :|

actually this is one of the reasons I refuse to watch news programs or tv in general now.

I know it sounds stupid, but once I saw the army ads (the ones earlier this year.. one of them was basically saying: "join the army, it's an amazing feeling of accomplishment you get when you successfully hit your target") I was so disgusted with the world I lived in that I refused to be part of such a 'socialisation system'.

well initially it wasn't disgusting, I laughed and thought that no 'australian' would agree with such a blatent disregard for 'non australian' human life. or indeed join the army in order to destroy it as if war was some sort of computer game, etc..

*pause* but I stopped feeling amused once I found out people not only didn't think of such ads as promoting the distribution of death to all, but as some sort of job recruitment thingo.. the way new is reported rather sickens me too. I don't really have much to say about it actually, I just refuse to watch the news or some ads. my parents think I'm insane. zhuo tries to get me to read newspapers, as does anna. *shrug*

*pause* and yes, I should be studying at the moment, and not reading very old blog entries and playing minesweeper and further ruining whatever meagre chances at recieving any marks whatsoever during exams.. =__= my guess is that I hate the being that is my self.

*runs away before aditya notices she's posted a comment on a really old entry*